Every Time I am in the area on Business I always try to get a pizza from Marty's. They do a fantastic job and really rate their pizzas as the best. Great People also

Great pizza!!!! Garlic bread a little under cooked but still good. Very affordable and good service.

We have lived across the street from Marty's pizza since 1973. The pizza has always been excellent. We have never been disappointed by anything ordered there. We highly recommend them for dine in, carry out or delivery.

Basically this is the best pizza in the Milwaukee area. Or at the very least, it's the most nostalgic. Between the 70s era wooden booths, the classic 80s-style arcade tucked away in a nook near the bathrooms, or the old-school square-style pizza slices that reminisce a by-gone era. My family has been customers at Marty's for over 20+ years and it's never disappointed. Even on the very last day of operation, despite the fact that the restaurant was severely understaffed and our pizza took nearly an hour to come, the quality was consistent to what I remember when I was a kid. It's just classic - the doughy yet still crispy crust, the nicely seasoned sauce, the loads of stringy cheese; the quality was consistent and you can tell they haven't skimped on the ingredients. I will really miss Marty's as the last of the quintessential Brookfield classics. Unfortunately I imagine the building will be bulldozed and turned into a cell phone store or another bank like the rest of the Bluemound road corridor.

First time here. Right now for some reason they are just doing pizza. Fine I'll go for it. So I liked it. Its in-between cracker and thin hand tossed. It was gooey and I liked the flavor of the sausage and sauce but would have liked having the bigger pieces of Canadian bacon because they were cut so small they got a little lost in knowing they were on the pizza. They have some good sizes for any party of people so you wouldn't have to worry about it if you had small to huge crowds to feed. Waitress was friendly and I could tell they have their share of regulars. I'd like to go back when they are making their other menu items. But for now pizza was pretty tasty im gonna be a regular I think

My husband & I placed an order on Saturday February 6th for carry out curbside pickup for our dinner. We have not been to Marty's in several years since we did not live close but was in the area that day & decided to give them a try. We are always looking for a deals & on their website they have coupon offers which was great. I was unsure on the size of their pizza's so I went for them to show me the size of the box & went from their to place our order. All the employee's wore masks & were very friendly. We order 14x14 pizza half pepp/half sausage & order of cheese garlic bread (2) for $20/$22 total. I told them where I was parked & said someone would bring out my order in 20-25 minutes. Once our order came out; I doubled checked our order before leaving; everything was correct & looked delicious. My husband & I enjoyed our food; the only suggestion we have would be to cook the garlic bread a little bit more. A tip definitely check their websites for coupons & you will also receive coupons on our orders as well.